Are You A Bad Manager? 12 Scary Signs!

blog thumbnail 19

What makes a manager bad? Nobody wants to believe they are a bad manager and we here would love to believe that every single reader of our blog is an incredibly talented and beloved manager. 

That being said we are also certain that none of the bad bosses of the world actually look into the mirror every day and ask themselves “Am I a bad manager?”. That level of self-awareness is truly hard to come by.

If we have to make a disclaimer here, this article is written with no particular intention of pointing fingers at anyone. Management isn’t all sunshine and rainbows. It is an incredibly complex practice with its own nuances that shouldn’t be taken lightly.

In this particular article, we will be dividing what can be seen as signs of bad management into four categories:

  • Communication Issues.
  • Team Dynamics.
  • Workload Management.
  • Behavioral Problems.

We know that in the hectic realm of modern work being an effective manager can be incredibly difficult. Exaggerated titles and sensational word choices aside, it is very easy to slip unintentionally and display some of the signs we’ve listed in this article. 

So without further ado, let’s explore the signs of bad management, elaborate on their details, and discuss how we as leaders can do better to create a more hospitable workplace for our direct reports.

All Managers Need Assistance

Keeping a team engaged and managing performance effectively is a lot easier said than done. A manager needs all the help they can get. Some of the best help you can get for managing performance comes in the form of Teamflect, the best performance management software for Microsoft Teams!

Whether you want to show your team support and appreciation through employee recognition or keep everyone focused and oriented through goal-setting, Teamflect has you covered on all performance management and performance review related fronts!

Manage performance inside Microsoft Teams
No sign-up required.
Teamflect Image

12 Signs Of A Bad Manager

Signs you are a bad manager!

Section 1: Communication Issues

Effective communication is one of the easiest areas of management for leaders to make mistakes in. Many managers while having all but positive intentions, unknowingly falter in this area, leading to a range of workplace issues. In this section, we will explore three key communication pitfalls that might indicate poor management practices.

1. Poor Listening Skills

One of the most critical yet often overlooked aspects of communication is listening. Managers are often praised highly for their effective speaking skills but listening as a skill can get a bit overlooked. Managers who fail to listen to their team members can miss out on valuable insights, feedback, and warning signs of bigger problems.

Improvement Tips: Practice active listening, which involves fully concentrating on the speaker, understanding their message, responding thoughtfully, and remembering the discussion. Encourage open dialogue and show genuine interest in team members’ inputs.

2. Lack of Clear Directions

Delegating and giving directions is a huge part of a manager’s day-to-day workload. When those directions aren’t very clear, there aren’t many employees who can call the manager out on the issue and seek clarification. Instead, teams are often left directionless and in a state of disarray.

Ambiguity in instructions can lead to mistakes, lack of priority, missed deadlines, and frustration among team members. It can also result in wasted time and resources as employees may need to redo tasks due to misunderstandings.

Improvement Tips: Before communicating tasks, ensure you have a clear understanding of the objectives and requirements. Be precise and direct in your instructions and always be open to questions and clarification from your team.

3. Overuse of The Wrong Communication Channels

As organizations are leaning more towards digital communication platforms and intra-company networks, the choice of communication channels becomes more and more important. While digital communication tools are essential in today’s workplace, relying solely on emails or IMs for complex or sensitive issues can be problematic.

Important nuances, emotions, and details can be lost in written communication, leading to misunderstandings, misinterpretations, and a lack of personal connection.

Improvement Tips: There is no replacement for a good old-fashioned one-on-one with the boss. Meet with your direct reports one-on-one on a regular basis. Use digital communication for straightforward, informational purposes and save nuanced discussions for more direct communication channels.

Section 2: Team Dynamics and Morale

Are you a bad manager: Conflicts in the workplace

Management style plays a massive part in how a team functions. As incredibly complex organisms, there is often no way to truly manage a team perfectly. Every decision a manager makes has the power to have an adverse effect on team dynamics and overall morale.

If you’re seeing signs of unrest or disengagement among your team, it always helps to take a step back and look at how your actions might have affected your team.

4. Playing Favorites

There are no two ways around it. Favoritism has no place in the workplace and it is one of the telltale signs of a bad manager.  That said many workplace biases are often unintentional. Maybe it’s the employee who always laughs at your jokes or the one who seems to think just like you.

When you start giving preferential treatment, whether it’s more interesting projects, leniency on deadlines, or just your attention, it doesn’t go unnoticed.

Improvement Tips: Try to spread your attention and opportunities evenly. It’s not just about being fair; it’s about bringing out the best in everyone. Every team member has unique strengths and it is your job to recognize and nurture them.

5. Ignoring Team Conflicts

Conflict is unavoidable wherever people spend too much time together.  As much as we’d love to believe our team is a big, happy family, clashes happen and that’s not always a bad thing.

Conflict can lead to growth and new ideas, but only if it’s managed correctly. One of the worst things a bad manager can do is to avoid conflict and let it fester.

Improvement Tips: When you overlook conflicts, it’s not just the issue that grows; it’s the gap between your team members. Address conflicts head-on. Facilitate open discussions where everyone feels heard. Your role? Be the mediator, not the dictator.

6. Failing to Recognize or Reward Achievements

A little employee praise goes a long way. Remember how great it felt when someone acknowledged your hard work? Your team feels the same. Everyone wants to feel appreciated and know their work matters.

Improvement Tips: It’s not always about grand gestures. A simple “thank you” or “great job” can boost morale incredibly. And when there’s a significant achievement, acknowledge it publicly. It’s about creating a culture where effort and success are recognized and celebrated.

Section 3: Workload and Performance Management

Navigating the delicate balance of workload and performance management is a key aspect of effective leadership. Missteps in this area can lead to burnout, disengagement, and a decline in team performance. Let’s delve into three critical signs that your approach to workload and performance management might need a rethink.

7. Overloading Employees

There’s a fine line between challenging your team and overloading them. While it’s great to push for high performance, consistently piling on more work than your team can handle is a recipe for disaster.

Are your team members regularly working late or during weekends? Is there an air of constant stress and rushing in the office? These could be signs that you’re overloading them.

Improvement Tips: It’s crucial to have open conversations about workload. Encourage your team to speak up if they’re feeling overwhelmed. Regularly review and adjust workloads and deadlines to ensure they’re realistic. Remember, a burnt-out team is not an efficient team.

8. Micromanaging

Micromanaging can be a hard habit to break. It often comes from a place of wanting things done ‘just right,’ but it can stifle your team’s creativity and growth. Micromanagement is not only the sign of a bad manager but also the sign of a manager who cares. What needs to be done is to redirect that care and attention somewhere else.

Do you find yourself constantly checking in on your team’s work, giving overly detailed instructions for simple tasks, or struggling to delegate? Then you could be micromanaging as we speak!

Improvement Tips: Trust is key. Start by delegating small tasks and gradually increase the level of autonomy. Provide clear expectations and then step back. Allow your team to approach tasks in their own way. This not only boosts their confidence but can also lead to innovative solutions.

9. Ignoring Employee Development

In the hustle of daily tasks, it’s easy to overlook the professional growth of your employees. However, neglecting this aspect can lead to stagnation and a lack of motivation.

If you can’t remember the last time you discussed career goals with your team members or provided opportunities for skill enhancement, you might be neglecting their development.

Improvement Tips: Regularly check in with your team members about their career aspirations. Provide opportunities for training, workshops, and cross-functional projects. Encourage mentorship within the team. Remember, when your team grows, so does your business.

If you need help with employee development, you should definitely check out our guide on:

Section 4: Personal Traits and Behavior

Are you a bad manager: Empathy in the workplace

In this final section, let’s turn the lens inward. Management isn’t just about strategies and skills; it’s deeply rooted in who you are as a person. Your traits and behaviors have a profound impact on your team. Here are three personal aspects you might need to examine:

10. Lack of Empathy

Empathy in management means genuinely understanding and sharing the feelings of your team. It’s about seeing things from their perspective and showing genuine concern for their well-being.

If you find yourself frequently dismissing employee concerns as trivial, or if you’re often surprised by high staff turnover or low morale, it could be a sign of lacking empathy.

Improvement Tips: Try to actively listen and understand your team’s viewpoints. Show compassion and offer support, especially in challenging times. Remember, empathy doesn’t mean always agreeing, but it does mean always caring and considering.

11. Inconsistency

Consistency in behavior and decisions is key to building trust. When you’re unpredictable, it can create confusion and insecurity among your team.

So here are a few simple questions. Do you find yourself changing goals or expectations frequently? Do your moods dictate your decisions more than the facts at hand? These are signs that inconsistency might be an issue.

Improvement Tips: Work on being more predictable in your decisions and reactions. Set clear, consistent expectations and stick to them. When changes are necessary, communicate them clearly and provide context to your team.

12. Deflecting Blame

As a manager, you’re not just responsible for your success, but also for your team’s failures. Blaming others when things go wrong undermines your credibility and trust.

If you find yourself often pointing fingers at others or making excuses for poor outcomes, it’s a sign you’re not taking accountability.

Improvement Tips: Practice owning up to mistakes and viewing them as learning opportunities. Lead by example and create a culture where it’s safe to admit and learn from failures.

ebook image

Keep up with all the latest developments in the world of remote work!

Written by Emre Ok

Emre is a content writer at Teamflect who aims to share fun and unique insight into the world of performance management.

thumbnail Interview Feedback Example

30 Best Candidate Interview Feedback Examples

feedback sandwich thumbnail

Feedback Sandwich: Examples, Pros & Cons, Best Practices