Annual Performance Review Template (with Self-Review)

This annual performance review template is designed for organizations that want to go beyond one-sided evaluations. Teamflect’s annual review template combines manager feedback with employee self-assessments, creating a balanced and insightful performance conversation. The most important aspect of this template is that

Whether you're reviewing OKR progress, evaluating core competencies, or gathering feedback on company values, this template ensures nothing slips through the cracks.

Use this template in Teamflect now

What does the Annual Performance Review with Self-Review template include?

Self-Evaluation Section

Invite employees to reflect on their key accomplishments, challenges, and growth opportunities over the past year.

Goal Review Module

Review the employee’s goal performance within the review period, built-in progress tracking, and space for written reflections by both parties.

Competency Assessment

Evaluate how the employee’s performance correlates with the competency framework associated with their role.

Core Values Assessment

Evaluate how the employee exemplifies your company’s core values with customizable rating scales.

Manager Feedback Section

A structured space for managers to highlight strengths, suggest improvements, and align future expectations.

Cultural & Collaboration Questions

Explore topics like team contribution, peer relationships, and how well the employee supports a thriving culture.

Auto-Generated Review Summary

Teamflect turns the full review into a clean visual summary, including a radar chart and overall performance score.

Integrated Development Plan

Conclude the review with clear, trackable development goals linked directly to future 1:1s, feedback cycles, and employee development goals.

Verification Section

Digital sign-off fields for reviewers and reviewees to finalize the process, ensuring mutual acknowledgment and documentation.

How to use the annual performance review template in Microsoft Teams & Outlook?

Following these simple steps, you can integrate this particular annual review template as well as other performance evaluation templates into your workflow inside Microsoft Teams, Outlook, or the browser of your choice, with Teamflect:

Customize the template to fit your needs

Use the template as is or customize it to fit your needs and culture. Add or remove questions, choose whether to include the self-review, and select the competencies and goals you want to evaluate. Select from a wide variety of question types such as: open-ended, multiple-choice, ranking, rating, Likert scale, and more.

Sending the templates out to employees

Choose who will be reviewed and select the corresponding manager. You can initiate reviews for individuals or in bulk. You also have the option to automate any performance review template so the template is sent out to teams in intervals of your choice, automatically.

Collaborate directly inside Microsoft Teams

Both the reviewer and reviewee complete their sections within Microsoft Teams or Outlook without switching tools or downloading documents.

Track progress and schedule conversations

Managers and HR can monitor completion rates, send reminders, and schedule follow-up 1:1s directly from within Teamflect.

View detailed insights & Power BI reports

View performance review insights in bulk or for each employee. Analyze performance review results with AI to derive insights. Integrate performance review data into Power BI to create comprehensive reports & dashboards.

Who should use this template?

This template is ideal for organizations that want to conduct structured, reflective, and collaborative annual reviews without leaving Microsoft Teams or Outlook.

It’s a great fit for:

  • HR teams rolling out company-wide employee performance management system
  • People managers conducting end-of-year evaluations for their direct reports
  • Team leads seeking more transparent, two-way performance conversations
  • Remote or hybrid organizations that need digital, asynchronous review workflows
  • Companies with goal- and value-based performance frameworks that want to track alignment

Whether you’re managing a small team or overseeing hundreds of reviews, this template helps ensure consistency, fairness, and actionable insights across the board.

Suggested Reading

Best practices to help HR run more effective performance reviews

Annual Reviews vs. Continuous Performance Management: Which Works Best?

How to prepare for a performance review

Use this template in Teamflect now

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some of the most frequently asked and heavily researched questions about review templates.

What is the purpose of Annual Performance Review template?

How often/when should I conduct Annual Performance Review?

How does Annual Performance Review contribute to the company?

What topics/areas does Annual Performance Review template focus on?

What should I write in my annual performance review?

How do you write an annual performance summary?

Suggested Templates