HR and Performance Management: Roles, Systems & Processes

What is HR Performance Management?

Let’s clear something up first. When we say HR performance management, we’re not just talking about annual performance reviews or handing out ratings once a year.

HR performance management is the structured process HR teams use to help employees perform at their best, consistently. 

It’s the system that brings together goal setting, feedback, reviews, development, and recognition under one strategy. And most importantly, it ties individual growth to company goals.

That means HR’s involvement isn’t just operational. It’s strategic. Performance management becomes a tool to:

• Align people with business objectives
• Track progress over time
• Identify high-potential talent
• Spot and solve performance issues early
• Support managers with data and structure
  
  

In other words, it’s the engine behind high-performing teams.

Of course, this is just the short version. If you’re looking for a deep dive into what performance management actually is with definitions, benefits, frameworks, and more, we’ve put together a full guide that breaks it all down. You can check out our dedicated article here:
👉 What is Performance Management? The Complete Guide‍

But for now, just keep this in mind:

‍
HR performance management is about building a culture where people know what’s expected, get the feedback they need, and have the tools to grow. 

That’s the foundation everything else is built on.

‍

What is the Role of HR in Performance Management?

While managers handle the day-to-day coaching and reviews, it’s HR that builds the system those conversations live in.

From designing the performance review process to training managers on how to give feedback, HR is the team that turns performance management from a checklist into a culture.

Here’s what that actually looks like in practice:

• Setting the strategy: HR defines what performance management should accomplish. Is the focus on employee development? Retention? Succession planning? Without a clear objective, everything else falls flat.
  
  
• Creating the structure: Performance reviews, 360 feedback, development plans, OKRs, competencies—all of these need a framework. HR creates the structure that keeps the process fair, consistent, and scalable.
  
  
• Supporting managers: Not every manager is a natural leader. HR equips them with the tools and training to have meaningful performance conversations. This is where templates, guidelines, and performance management software (like Teamflect) really come in handy.
  
  
• Tracking and analyzing data: HR turns performance data into insights. Who’s thriving? Who needs support? Where are the skill gaps? These insights drive decisions around promotions, learning programs, and even organizational design.
  
  
• Driving fairness and consistency: Left unchecked, performance management can become biased or inconsistent across teams. HR ensures that every employee, regardless of manager or department, has access to the same standards and opportunities.
  
  

So, what is HR’s role in performance management? In short: They make it possible. They make it work. And they make it matter.

The Importance of HR in Performance Management

When HR isn’t taking charge of performance management, things start to fall apart and fall apart quickly.

Managers get overwhelmed. Employees lose direction. Reviews become inconsistent. And what started as a well-meaning process turns into paperwork nobody wants to do.

Performance management needs structure, accountability, and alignment with company goals. That structure doesn't magically appear. It's built and maintained by HR.

And here’s the kicker: companies know it’s broken.

As we've previously highlighted in our article on the major objectives of performance management:

"Only 32% of HR leaders say their performance management process delivers what they need."

That’s not just a sign of inefficiency.

It’s a sign that organizations are missing out on real opportunities to grow, retain, and develop their talent.

The involvement of HR in the performance management process brings clarity to the entire operation.

Without a direct involvement of human resources in performance management, processes such as performance reviews or 360-degree feedback cycles can slowly devolve into formalities.

When HR owns performance management:

• Goals are aligned from the top down, aka Cascading Goals
• Continuous feedback becomes a standard procedure.
• The right performance review frequency is found.
• Talent development strategies are built around organizational needs.
  

The alternative?

• Disconnected teams.
• Burned-out managers.
• High-performers walking out the door.

That’s why HR’s role in performance management is absolutely critical.

How Does HR Support Performance Management?

HR doesn’t just create the process. They keep it running, troubleshoot when things break down, and make sure every part of the system works together. Supporting performance management means stepping in at every stage, from rollout to refinement.

‍

1. Set up the systems

HR builds the foundation. That includes designing the performance review cycle, choosing the right tools, defining rating scales (or eliminating them), and setting the cadence for feedback, goal setting, and check-ins.

2. Train managers to manage performance

A big chunk of performance management fails because managers aren’t confident giving feedback or leading development conversations. HR plays the role of coach-for-the-coaches, equipping leaders with training, templates, and real-time support.

3. Reinforce culture through consistency

If feedback is only flowing in some departments or development goals are treated like a checkbox, performance management becomes lopsided. HR ensures that every team follows the same principles, so culture doesn’t get lost in translation.

4. Support with the right technology

 The best systems are the ones people actually use. That’s why HR should own the performance tech stack. From choosing software that integrates into daily workflows (like Microsoft Teams) to making sure it fits the company’s needs, HR keeps the digital side of performance on track.

‍

How Does the HR Performance Management Process Work?

You can’t improve what you can’t define. So let’s break performance management down into the key stages HR teams should build into the process.

While every company might tweak the steps slightly, this is the backbone of a healthy performance management cycle:

1. Goal Setting & Tracking

‍

HR helps define how goals should be set across the company.

Whether that’s OKRs, SMART goals, or KPI's. Goals are tied to broader company objectives, and employees understand what they’re working toward from day one.

While managers are the ones with the in depth knowledge on the capabilities of their direct reports, effective implementation of performance management lies in not what the goals are but how they are being set.

Implementing a cascading goal structure allows organizations to align each individual objective with team goals and overall organizational strategy.

2. Continuous Feedback

Performance feedback shouldn’t wait for the formal review.

HR creates feedback systems that allow for regular, real-time input between managers, peers, and direct reports.

Continuous feedback ensures that employees receive real-time input while their work is still fresh and relevant. This also means that the timely feedback that is delivered is actionable.

This, however, is easier said than done. That is why HR departments implement various feedback structures, systems, and loops in their organizations, usually through the use of feedback software.

The right feedback solution allows departments to standardize feedback through intuitive feedback templates.

Best practices:

• Use integrated tools to collect and share feedback seamlessly.
• Encourage feedback in both directions: managers to employees, and employees to managers.
• Normalize informal feedback with regular prompts inside team meetings or 1:1s.
• Provide training on how to give constructive feedback, especially in remote environments.
• Set a cadence, for example, monthly informal feedback plus a structured quarterly review.

‍

3. Performance Reviews

HR is responsible for designing a performance review process that balances structure with flexibility.

HR's role in implementing such a structure includes choosing the right review cadence (quarterly, biannual, or project-based), selecting review types (self-evaluations, manager reviews, 360 reviews), and standardizing evaluation criteria across the organization to avoid performance review biases.

HR can also take the role of calibrator in certain reviews to ensure fairness.

Best practices:

• Use competency-based or role-specific review templates.
• Train managers to avoid common pitfalls like recency bias or halo effect.
• Align review questions with company values, team goals, and individual responsibilities.
• Make reviews forward-looking include time for reflection, development goals, and planning the next steps.
• Use software that supports collaboration and transparency throughout the review process.

4. Development Planning

HR partners with managers and employees to create personalized, trackable development plans. These plans identify areas of improvement and outline a path that may include learning resources, stretch projects, mentorships, or role transitions. HR ensures these plans are aligned with business needs and reviewed regularly.

Best practices:

• Use Individual Development Plans to guide employees.
• Tie development goals to performance data, company competencies, or future roles.
• Incorporate learning and development tools (e.g., LinkedIn Learning, LMS platforms).
• Encourage managers to co-create plans with employees.

Helpful Resource: A Free Individual Development Plan Template

5. Follow-up & Iteration

Performance management isn’t one-and-done. HR checks in on the process itself:

• Are reviews happening?
• Are goals updated?
• Are development plans being used?
• Feedback from employees and managers helps refine the system continuously.

HR's true function in the performance management process is to ensure that the practices listed above, are more than formalities.

‍

What are HR Performance Management Systems?

HR performance management systems are the software solutions that bring structure, consistency, and visibility to the performance process. They’re where goal setting, feedback, reviews, and development planning actually happen.

A good system doesn’t just replace paperwork. It builds performance management into the way people already work.

Here’s what a modern HR performance management system typically includes:

• Goal and OKR tracking
• Performance review templates and workflows
• Real-time and 360-degree feedback
• Individual development plans
• Reporting dashboards for HR and leadership
• Integration with HRIS and productivity tools
  
  

And here’s where it gets critical: integration capabilities.

If your performance system lives outside of your team’s daily workflow, you’re fighting an uphill battle for adoption. That’s why integrations with platforms like Microsoft Teams and Outlook aren’t just nice to have but essential.

A system like Teamflect, for example, doesn’t require anyone to log into a new platform. It meets managers and employees where they already are: inside Microsoft Teams.

Manage performance inside Microsoft Teams

Try Teamflect for Free

No credit card required.

‍

HR Performance Management Examples with Teamflect

Now let’s get a little more specific. What does HR performance management look like in action? And how does a system like Teamflect make the process feel natural instead of forced?

Here are a few examples from real Teamflect use cases:

1. 360-Degree Feedback Without the Headache

Instead of juggling emails or random survey links, HR can launch a structured 360 feedback process directly inside Microsoft Teams. You choose the reviewers, set the questions, and track the feedback as it comes in without anyone leaving their flow of work.

2. Development Tracking That Doesn’t Disappear After Reviews

With Teamflect, performance reviews feed directly into individual development plans. So if an employee needs to work on a certain skill, you can assign a concrete goal, set milestones, and follow up on progress in your next 1:1 without switching tools.

3. Internal Mobility That Actually Uses Performance Data

Because Teamflect connects performance metrics with your HRIS, HR teams can identify high-potential employees and promote from within.

You can even link competencies to internal job boards, ensuring people grow into the right roles,not just available ones.

These aren’t just features! They’re real examples of what performance management looks like when it’s built for the way people actually work.

‍

Challenges of Performance Management in HR

Let’s not pretend this is easy. Even the best performance management strategy can fall flat if the challenges aren’t addressed head-on.

Here are the most common roadblocks HR teams run into:

1. Resistance from managers

Some managers see performance management as extra work—especially if they haven’t been trained on how to give feedback or coach employees effectively.

2. Low employee adoption

If the system is clunky or lives outside of the tools people use daily, engagement drops fast. Employees stop updating goals, feedback dries up, and reviews become checkbox exercises.

3. Lack of clarity or consistency

Without clear guidance from HR, every team ends up doing performance their own way. That makes the data messy, the process confusing, and the outcomes unreliable.

4. Disconnected systems

When your goals are in one tool, feedback in another, and reviews in a third, performance management becomes a scavenger hunt. And no one has time for that.

Here’s the good news: these challenges are solvable with the right support, the right systems, and the right mindset.

If you’re looking for a way to make performance management easier for everyone involved, from HR to managers to employees, Teamflect is solution.

It’s designed to work with Microsoft Teams and Outlook, so you can build a performance culture without asking people to adopt yet another platform.

Want to see what that looks like in action?

‍