When engagement survey responses drop, most companies blame survey fatigue. Elaine Lin Hering sees something else: people stop answering once they’ve learned that speaking up won’t change anything. In this episode of the Team Check-In, host Emre Ok sits down with Elaine, former Harvard Law School lecturer and author of the USA Today bestseller Unlearning Silence, to unpack silence as she defines it: the withholding of self for the comfort and convenience of others.
Elaine traces how the silence we learn growing up follows us into the workplace, and why telling people to “just speak up” rarely works. She shares the habits that shut colleagues down without anyone noticing, like the Friday 9 a.m. meeting that lands at 4 a.m. for the engineer with the key insight. She also walks through Albert Hirschman’s exit, voice and loyalty model to show what silence ends up costing a company, and what HR can do to change the math.
1. Silence is the withholding of self. Elaine defines it as holding back your thoughts and expertise to spare someone else discomfort, which costs teams the very insight they hired for.
2. Healthy silence is a choice. The line between strategic and oppressive silence is agency. Biting your tongue because you’ll raise it one-on-one later is a decision. Staying quiet out of habit isn’t.
3. Name the expectation, then ask in pairs. Without stated norms, people default to the lowest-risk option. Asking “what works?” alongside “what doesn’t?” gives bad news a standard place to land.
4. Design time for post-processors. Some people do their best thinking 20 minutes after the meeting ends. Teams that only reward fast, in-the-room answers miss that slower, deeper thinking.
5. People stop answering surveys when nothing visibly changes. You don’t need to act on every response right away, but you do need to say what you heard and when you’ll get to it.
6. What you allow becomes the rule. When a senior rainmaker gets a pass on bad behavior, everyone notices. Leaders shift the cost of speaking up by rewarding the people who flag problems early.
Emre (01:45.199)
all right. So yeah, it's just gonna be a casual conversation. I just started the recording and I'll just start by doing little intro and saying, hi everyone, welcome to another episode of the Team Check-In. But today we're exploring something very chill.
Very low stakes just the entire concept of silence itself and how work we are entrenched in it, how our entire lives are ruled by it, and of course, how it impacts the workplace from surveys to performance conversations, as well as the role HR can play in building systems that support the employee voice. And of course, there's no way I can do any of this alone. So, with me today, someone who has made a career helping people say the things that matter.
Elaine Lin Hering (02:13.271)
Yeah.
Emre (02:37.912)
Former managing partner at Triad Consulting Group and lecturer at Harvard Law, the best-selling author of Unlearning Silence, the model minority myth incarnate, and my second favorite audiobook narrator of all time, Elaine Lin Hering. Welcome to the show.
Elaine Lin Hering (02:52.801)
Thank you for having me. And now I'm like, who's your favorite audiobook narrator?
Emre (02:57.134)
well, it was Peter Serafinowicz who did like a couple who did a very short stint reading the Discworld novels. But he wasn't actually reading the whole thing, he was just the voice of death, and he was pretty cool. So the production value on those things are amazing, but okay, we are moving way too far a on a tangent, very early.
Elaine Lin Hering (03:18.199)
Love it. I mean, this is already a good conversation. We've talked about the voice of death and really big topics. So we know our listeners are in for some good real conversation.
Emre (03:29.29)
Amazing. I love it. And yeah, shout out to the Discworld series. Catch the audiobooks. They're amazing. But Elaine, welcome to the show. And I actually want to start things off with the audiobook because you narrated Unlearning Silence, the audiobook. How was that experience?
Elaine Lin Hering (03:46.538)
It was wonderful. I mean, I think in terms of career trajectories, it's a worthwhile lesson to know that nothing in your career is ever lost. So I actually grew up as a choral singer. I did some Grammy Award-winning recordings. So being back in the studio was not unfamiliar, even if it was in a different capacity. And that just feels like a life lesson for anyone navigating careers of, you know, when I was singing with the San Francisco Symphony, Symphony Chorus at
thirteen years old or something. I had no idea that being comfortable and familiar in a recording studio would come into play later in life.
Emre (04:27.374)
I mean, amazing. I have tons of questions, but I just want to start, you know, with again something. So what is silence?
Elaine Lin Hering (04:35.861)
Yeah, when I talk about silence, this isn't the meditative moment on your yoga mat. I define silence as the withholding of self for the comfort and convenience of others. And I'll repeat that because it's significant. The withholding of self, your self-editing, your thoughts, your insights, your expertise, your perspective that could change the project or the company out of deference to someone else's comfort or convenience.
Right. People get defensive if you push back. Your manager's like, Well, you're wrong, and you don't want to deal with that relational risk. And so you withhold your thoughts and insights, which of course has huge ramifications in the workplace and in life.
Emre (05:20.406)
That's wonderful. And I love, you know, how you explain it as withholding yourself. And speaking of yourself, what actually inspired you to tackle silence as a topic?
Elaine Lin Hering (05:34.924)
Frustration. Frustration with I I grew up in the Harvard negotiation world. Grew up professionally, I should say. I taught getting to yes, this classic negotiation textbook, getting to yes, difficult conversations, skills around giving and receiving feedback, all of that from my colleagues in the Harvard world. And I think a lot of those tools are useful. I also taught across six continents, all industries, different levels of seniority, and I noticed some people still wouldn't negotiate.
Some people still wouldn't have the difficult conversations, no matter how much HR told them they should. Which to me begs the question well, why not? What are we missing? Not that you need a Harvard remedial course. And what I noticed was silence. We're not talking about the ways that employees, human beings, have learned to edit or withhold of themselves, and also the ways that we as colleagues
incentivize people to stay silent and certainly how our policies and practices also support some and silence others. So Unlearning Silence was, let's, we cannot solve what we cannot accurately see. And so if we're gonna just tell people you need to be more confident, you need to have more courage, you need to be more assertive, like go take some more leadership training that's not going to get at the core issue, which is silence. We're wasting time, money and energy. So I decided to tackle silence.
Emre (07:00.91)
Amazing. And I love the way you approach it, all the different types of silences you mention in the book. But I think two things that you very stand out very much in you know the introduction that you just gave us is there are just as much as silence itself has been glorified as we grow up, right? We learn to keep our head down, we learn to listen. As we grow up, as we become adults in the workplace.
Speaking up and saying things are also glorified, but in a more empty and vague way. You know, your voice means the world to us. Why didn't you just speak up? Why didn't you say something? Just just talk to your boss. I'm sure that will solve everything. And I think there's a huge dichotomy there, right? If we grow up, if the if the entire system and the world is telling us that actually we should stay silent, I don't think we can fix all of that with a bunch of motivational posters.
Elaine Lin Hering (07:40.203)
Mm-hmm.
Elaine Lin Hering (07:59.416)
Completely agree. And I'm loving how you outlined it, which is we are rewarded for silence. And even as well-intentioned leaders say, just speak up, your voice matters, you're essential, often their actions and reactions actually incentivize silence more because especially working cross-culturally and on global teams, it's well, you're rocking the boat.
Right. You're slowing down the process. We could deliver on time, but for the fact that you said there's a bug in the system. Right. Now that bug is going to come back and bite us in six months, but I may or may not still be accountable for the project then. frankly, I may or may not be on the team then. And so there are the short-term, long-term costs. And also, so often we put the onus on someone else to say, you know, you grew up in a quiet
Child, you had a quiet childhood or or household, the problem is you, versus there is self-silencing, which is mind to own. There is social silencing, which is how do we incentivize behavior on our teams? And there's systemic silence, which is we do need policies and practices, and we need to be really intellectually honest about the it differential impacts those policies and practices have on different people.
Emre (09:18.842)
So let's actually start things off with the silence we learned, the silence that we actually bring to the table, right? Because I mean so much of the empty advice around silence is actually saying, you know, just speak up, just say it. So one of those core things holding us back from it is the silence we learned. So what is it and how does it actually show up in the work?
Elaine Lin Hering (09:34.444)
Mm-hmm.
Elaine Lin Hering (09:44.438)
Yeah, let me actually start with my own story. I'm the youngest daughter of an immigrant family from Taiwan to the United States. I come from an Asian household where to respect my elders means to keep my mouth shut. And I thought it was just me and my family of origin. And as I started to do this work, I was talking with my Latina sisters around the world who taught me a phrase that their abuelas, their grandmothers, had taught them Calladita te ves más bonita.
Which in restly translated from Spanish to English is you're prettier when you're shut up. Right? It is easier for other people. You are more delightful as part of the family or the team when you don't rock the boat, when you don't push back. Again, we go back to our original definition of silence as withholding of self for the comfort and convenience of others, right? Smile and look pretty, and everyone else gets to do what they want to do. They don't have to reckon with.
challenging realities. So I learned that to be a good family member, a good team player was put my head down, work hard, you know, don't demand anything, don't don't try to get promoted because your work should speak for yourself. And that worked really well as an entry-level person. Everyone wanted me on my team, on their team or group project, but also means that your real voice, which is just a term for your thoughts, insights, and expertise,
Isn't actually present. And so we have to ask on our teams if you have team members, why are they there? Presumably to add value, especially in the age of AI when if you just want to outsource things to get done, you can have an agent do that. So if you have someone on your team, I am assuming that they are adding value by bringing perspective, insights, thoughts, expertise.
And how do you actually get to surface that so you don't just have the loudest voices, but you have the best ideas coming forth is to honor that everyone has a different perspective. And to the extent that you're someone like me who learned to defer to people with more hierarchical power or who present as older than you, the unlearning is to say, what assumptions do I carry about whether my opinion or perspective matters?
Elaine Lin Hering (12:06.473)
And is it serving me today? And if it's not serving who I am today and who I want to become, what might I try to do differently? Right? Our habits over time, our learned silence is not permanent. But so often it is a habitual, almost instinctive response rather than a conscious choice.
Emre (12:28.694)
That's incredible. And I just want to say, first of all, listening to all of this live is even 10 times better than the audiobook. So once again, very happy that you're on the show. But I want to do a little bit of housekeeping. Does unlearning silence mean I just get to say whatever I want?
Elaine Lin Hering (12:52.391)
Absolutely not. The world is far too noisy to say everything to everyone all the time, right? Everyone already has an opinion about everything. And so if you listen to nothing else in the book, chapter three is when silence makes sense. It's also what differentiates my work from anything else in the market, which is we so often hear, just speak up, make your voice known. And that can feel exhausting.
It is also diminishing of the reality that we need wisdom and discernment of when do you want to offer your energy, your insights, your expertise? What is the context you're in? Right? Just speak up all the time to everyone ignores the reality of real relationships, political dynamics, costs, how much you can absorb, your own agency to choose. So the difference between silence that is additive and strategic.
Or oppressive is agency. Are you choosing it? Right. I'm going to bite my tongue now because I know that this leader doesn't like to be called out in a large group and I'm going to talk with them later. Or I'm going to say something in this large group, even if it pisses them off, because actually I'm not saying it to them. I'm saying it to shape the team culture because I want to signal to the team that this sort of behavior is unacceptable on our team.
Right, really thinking about where, when, with whom do I choose to share my thoughts, insights, and expertise. And only you get to choose that for yourself.
Emre (14:29.112)
Do you think, I mean, we just talked about the you know silence that we learned growing up that is coming from you know our roots? It's what it's it's a bit like the baggage we bring to the workplace. I mean, growing up, and I know like it's not a massive, it's not it's kind of a champagne problem, but growing up, my family had, you know, a massive change in our financial status, not on the positive direction. My dad got a new job, new school, new pro new so new school.
Elaine Lin Hering (14:39.818)
Absolutely.
Emre (14:58.636)
New friends, new people are all around me that have had a completely different upbringing. But it led me to think, these guys are inherently better than me. They know things that I don't. So if I'm gonna say something, I gotta make sure I don't embarrass myself, because what if I do? And for the longest time, I brought that into the workplace, oddly enough, as someone who talks for a living. Right? So there's some.
We all bring all of this into the workplace. But how can people around us be responsible for our baggage? So our podcast is predominantly listened by HR professionals whose it's their job is to help employees find their voice, to help employees help create a workspace where everyone feels heard. But how is my high school trauma the responsibility of our HR person?
Elaine Lin Hering (15:57.866)
I'd say it's not. It's not their responsibility. It is your responsibility, right? Which is why we look at the silence cycle and the different types of silence, what is mine to own. And it is HR's responsibility to deal with reality, of which everybody's high school trauma, is part of the fabric of the reality that we're solving for. I'd also say there are really powerful and not
Emre (16:04.686)
Mm-hmm.
Elaine Lin Hering (16:26.517)
All that difficult levers for HR or any leader in the workplace to pull in terms of voice. So, number one, are you making really clear the expectation on this team and in this organization? Because what was true in high school does not have to be true here. But unless someone articulates that very clearly, our brains fill in the assumptions or don't even realize the assumptions we hold. Like in a meeting.
Do you have to raise your hand and be called on in order to offer an answer? Or is it speak now? Right? What are the team norms? And if they're not articulated, especially if you're new or more junior, you're looking around of how do things work around here? And it makes sense for you to take sort of the lower risk. Risk mitigation means let me stay with silence until I'm told otherwise. So can you tell otherwise? Name the expectation. Second, what
sources of voice do we count as valid? And what I mean by that is one of the ways that we silence people is we expect them to all speak in three succinct bullet points with no ums, just the right amount of emotion to show that you care, but not too much, particularly if you're a woman or present that way, that you come across as overly emotional. Right? That's a very narrow definition of what acceptable voice sounds like versus
it's both okay to talk and to type, right? Whatever way makes it easier for you to communicate, we want to hear from you in that way. It's also in a conversation lowering the stakes of look, we're not looking for perfection here. You don't have to be fully buttoned up. We are literally trying to brainstorm and problem solve, right? So that might be give me your first draft thinking. I'm not looking for polished edits, just get it out there.
Give me your first draft. So we're lowering the expectation, lowering the stakes, saying to people, it's okay if it's not a fully formed, fully baked, polished thought, right? Can we redefine what acceptable voice looks and sounds like? And those are all levers that we can pull all the time, right? So I think a third is if we want to guard against toxic positivity, can we embed standard questions? Because
Elaine Lin Hering (18:51.383)
Usually it's not as hard for people to say the good stuff, right? You're gonna agree with the leader, agree with leadership, but where the value really comes in is what are we missing? What about this doesn't resonate? What about this doesn't work? Tell us now. and so instead of just saying us number one, assuming that people are gonna speak up, or number two, saying, what do you think? What do you think can feel like a trap versus what about this idea works? What about this doesn't work?
Or what are the pros, what are the cons? Notice that there are pairs of compliment questions that everybody can expect, and you get both the good and the bad. And then if you want bonus points, communicate the expectation again, which was advice number one of we're looking for the good, bad, and the ugly here because that's the only way we're gonna get better. But unless you put a line in the sand to say we are actually looking for the good, bad, and the ugly, human behavior is just gonna tell you the good.
Emre (19:50.991)
I mean, I think this ties into something that I wanted to talk to about further down the line. I absolutely love the sense in your book that expression doesn't have to be perfect, right? When we're trying to listen to someone who is trying to voice something, we need to focus on what they're trying to say and not what we're hearing. As you mentioned, lowering the stakes. Because
Communication is always touted as, you know, of course, like the skill the a must-have skill, right? Or they must they have to be a good communicator. And it is an important skill. But when we're trying to listen to someone, we shouldn't our perception of what they're saying shouldn't be limited to their you know capacity of expressing themselves perfectly. So I absolutely love that angle. But I just wanted to get back to so.
We talked about the silence we learned, the one we bring in, but obviously there's the silence that the company culture teaches us. Right? So how does that show up? How can how does you know systemic silencing show up in an organization's culture?
Elaine Lin Hering (21:02.423)
I am laughing a little bit because there are so many different ways, but there is systemic silence and then there are cultural norms. And that to me are two different aspects. The systemic silence you might equate with employee silence or and it is this
By the way, Emre, we just you froze on my screen. I don't know if that means you're still here. Okay, great. I just figured we'd check before we keep talking.
Emre (21:31.579)
yeah, it's gonna be sorted out real quick. Just
Elaine Lin Hering (21:39.832)
So there is employee silence and organizational silence, this collective phenomenon of saying nothing because people don't believe it's worth it. So there are a couple ways that this shows up. One is literally what are our policies and practices? And around the world, this is why the return to office post COVID has, it just feels like it's dragged on, right? We why are we still talking about this? Well, it is an example of one policy that supports some people.
Who lead better in person, who have short commutes, who don't benefit as much from flexibility, and silences or makes incrementally harder, exponentially harder for people who benefit from that flexibility to show up and lend their talents. So one is just the policy side. And then the other is if we haven't defined the cultural expectations on this team or in a company, then people are observing what happens around here.
And can often conclude it's not worth it to speak up around here because Qi Ming said something and the leader snapped at them, and Qi Ming is no longer here. Right? The the data points that people have, especially if there's not messaging and narrative around it, lead us to conclusions of how do things work around here? I guess we don't question the VP or we don't question the CEO.
And the way that you change that is the leader or policy-wise needs to say, here, this is what we do. Right? Here we ask what's missing. Here we say, I see it differently. And here you don't, you don't get fired for doing that. You don't get disappeared for doing that. And both the articulation expectation and the consequence need to be present.
and even better if you own the narrative around it. But what so often happens is there is no distinct articulation of the desired culture, the cultural expectations, and people are just watching passively of okay, they're they're not on the team anymore. They're they don't work here anymore. I guess we don't do that around here because I need to take care of myself, right? That that is a human calculation that makes complete sense.
Elaine Lin Hering (24:05.117)
And the only way to counterbalance it is with intentionality.
Emre (24:10.966)
I love that. And I think you kinda sort of got into the territory of what I wanted to ask you next, which was so
Come coming at it from a human resources perspective once again, if someone, if an HR professional looks at their workplace, and how do they how does an HR professional spot this culture of silencing employees in their organization? Because if that, because if you know that culture is fully ingrained in the organization, well, nobody's gonna say anything about it, right?
It's not going to show up in an employee engagement survey. Maybe the employee engagement survey won't even be completed. So how how can an HR person, how can an HR professional spot, you know, this culture of silencing in their company?
Elaine Lin Hering (25:03.991)
Let me start with deep appreciation and gratitude to HR because it is such a hard and often thankless role, right? Everyone, leaders come to you to have you deal with the conversations that they don't want to have or are ill-equipped to have and are sort of outsourcing what is often their responsibility. and then you're probably under-resourced and underfunded as well. So let's let's start there.
I'd also argue that HR professionals are incredibly smart. You are observing the world around you and probably have experienced it yourself, which is as you look at leadership, what behaviors are they rewarding? Meaning, do they reward either by promotion or by a relationship or by celebration people who push back, people who have differences of opinion?
I mean, you you have senses you're part of this team too, as much as you play a a distinct function. And if you are observing that, that there are ramifications for people who, you know, cross someone else, I would be asking the hard questions to leadership of what culture are you really trying to build here and why it matters from a psychological safety perspective, from a retention perspective, from a cost perspective of how much is it costing us?
Every time we need to backfill these roles, that it's often everybody knows and is just not talking about it. And I would say that there's disproportionate responsibility on leadership to be really clear of what type of organization and culture you're trying to create. There are some organizations that are not trying to create a psychological, safe psychologically safe workplace.
Right. It's just come in, do your job, get it done. It is utterly transactional. Let's be really honest about what we're trying to create. Because if there's any discrepancy between people's words and actions, employees know that. the second is to be really honest with yourself of what are we allowing? Because what we allow becomes the rule.
Elaine Lin Hering (27:24.113)
And what I the specific example I have in mind is often there is a rainmaker or someone very senior who's important to the business, important enough that even though we say we are zero tolerance, even though we say, you know, y y you should actually listen to people, respect people, we care about human beings, that person gets a pass because they bring in enough money, because you know, they were the founder, whatever it is.
If you allow that behavior and leadership decides to allow that behavior, then that is actually the culture that you're creating. Because it's not just an exception, it actually becomes the rule that everybody sees, everybody knows. my experience is it's not invisible to HR, even if it doesn't show up on an employee survey.
Right. You could get that data to say we only had a 42% completion rate or response rate, but actually HR smart. HR knows. And the question is, what are we as HR going to do about it? Particularly if we also feel on the receiving end of being silenced because you're just a cost function, right? You're not HR isn't key to the business. How is HR treated within the organization is another factor. And it to me goes back to
Emre (28:37.218)
Mm.
Elaine Lin Hering (28:48.613)
it can feel so overwhelming to do anything about it. And what is within our sphere of influence, which battles do we want to fight? Where do we want to start? Right. All of that is a genic, again, meaning going back to your own agency of where are you going to spend your time and energy, knowing that we all only have 24 hours a day and only have one life to live, right? This is why you, even as HR, get to decide where where are you going to spend your time and energy? Where are you going to put your voice?
Emre (29:18.762)
I mean, that was absolutely brilliant. And I agree with you when you said HR is one of the most heavily stigmatized departments in the workplace today. There are a thousand different stereotypes around the, you know, the HR person, the people professional. In fact, and it is a department that consistently has to justify its own existence, right? Because they are being seen as the policy police. They are being seen as the
Elaine Lin Hering (29:26.263)
Mm.
Emre (29:47.417)
Group of people who say like, you know, they throw the pizza parties every once in a while. And they just do job interviews. Where in fact these are people who are responsible for the most valuable asset an organization has, right? It's the by far its biggest investment. They they're responsible for their people. So there is a certainly a stigma.
Elaine Lin Hering (30:01.387)
Mm-hmm.
Emre (30:14.752)
I also want to say what I love about your book is that, I mean, one, we discussed how it's not just, you know, talking about, we are being silenced like that, it's just that. Just speak up. You actually go into the details of every single type, different type of sentence, silence, but you also don't just poke the finger at others and say, look, big bad corporate is silencing us, or big bad society, silence me, big bad person.
Is silencing us, but you're actually talking about how we ourselves can take the role of the silencer very easily, how we can silence other people, either knowingly or unknowingly. So the question is, how do we silence those around us in the workplace without actually noticing it?
Elaine Lin Hering (31:04.735)
Yeah, this is chapter five of the book, and we've actually talked about two ways that we unintentionally silence people. One is by not naming the operating assumption, right? If if I grew up in a household or I'm from a culture where I've got something to say, I'm just gonna say it, I very naturally assume that everyone else operates the same way. And so that active invitation to say,
There is an expectation here to offer your thoughts, insights, expertise. We wouldn't have hired you if we didn't think that you had something to offer. And then training leaders to say, you know, Joanna, what's on your mind or what are we missing? And invite them into the conversation is number one, right? Can we get on the same page as to the expectation? Number two was expecting everyone to speak in the same way. And it is not just listening.
Or active listening, but listening across differences, differences of perspective, differences of style, that how we show up and how we communicate. There might be one dominant norm or expectation, but communication is multi way, right? It's not just someone else needs to fit into my paradigm in order to be heard. It is how do we create the environment where we can get the best thoughts, insights, and expertise? And that often shows up in lots of different ways. So those are two.
I I would say the third is that we assume everyone is like us. And that is certainly in how we communicate, but most specifically in how we process information. So there are two main ways that human beings process information. There are real-time processors where the more we talk through something in the moment, the more clear the idea gets. This is in contrast to post-processors.
Where if you've ever sat in a meeting, you can't quite figure out what to say, 20 minutes after you click out of the virtual room or you leave the conference room, you're like, that's what I would have said. Welcome to being a post-processor. And in an instantaneous society, that everything should have been done yesterday or two weeks ago, we don't often create time or design time for people to think.
Elaine Lin Hering (33:24.511)
What a novel idea that we might actually process information in different ways. And again, if we want not just the loudest, fastest thoughts, but the best thinking, how do we design the way that we work to actually facilitate what some people might call 2 a.m. thinking or like the thought I had in the shower because I do my best thinking there? Do we have time for people to sleep on it?
The parallel of this work is Economist Daniel Kahneman's work around slow and fast thinking, right? Fast thinking is instinctive, quick, immediate. slow thinking is deliberate, reflective. We need both in order to make good decisions and get to good outcomes. But if we've only designed the rhythms of how we communicate and work to be quick and instantaneous, we are missing out on that deep reflective thinking.
that actually leads us to better outcomes. So that's three different ways we silence other people unintentionally. There's six more in the book. I I will say that let me give you a fourth, which is just who's present in the conversation. Often we think, well, I I don't know if we actually think this, but we default to adding more people to the calendar meeting. Let's get everybody in the room because then we'll be on the same page. Doesn't happen.
Emre (34:44.79)
Mm.
Elaine Lin Hering (34:49.877)
Right? You've got everyone in that Zoom room, but actually people are tuned out, there's bad internet connection. It's actually not serving the function. And so the question is: is the mode and medium, the way that we work together, actually supporting the desired outcomes? And that's a question that we need to ask that we
Don't pause enough to reflect because well, we've always had a 9 a.m. meeting on Friday. Never mind that it is 4 a.m. somewhere else for the key engineer who has the insight. And we need to acknowledge the reality that as global teams, distributed teams, there is no perfect time zone. But let us not assume that it is an even playing ground if I'm asking someone to get on a call at 2 a.m. their local time, because it is 9 a.m. in New York, for example.
Emre (35:40.053)
I absolutely love it. And one of the, you know, ways that you mention in the book that I actually want to touch upon here is not engaging with someone's input, right? Even if we can actually implement it. We just talked about employee engagement surveys in the workplace. A lot a massive complaint about engagement surveys is, completion rates are down. Why do you think that is? It's not.
Elaine Lin Hering (36:04.695)
Mm-hmm.
Emre (36:07.052)
Because I will tell you, as someone who makes, you know, as a part of a company that makes engagement survey software, it's not the software. I I I don't want to like push the blame out of our way, but it's not the tool. And it's not just ours, right? Good engagement survey software are a dime a dozen. Conducting strong and effective surveys is not hard when it comes to the infrastructure. However, the reason people don't actually
Elaine Lin Hering (36:30.294)
Mm-hmm.
Emre (36:33.57)
Complete the engagement survey or they stop responding to the engagement survey is they don't think it will change anything. They don't think, they don't think you know it's gonna be worth taking those extra five minutes to complete that survey because it's not going to amount to anything. Your input is not gonna result in change, right? And one thing you actually mention in the book that I love is.
Elaine Lin Hering (36:40.727)
Completely.
Emre (37:00.138)
You n you don't necessarily ha need to have the capacity to implement that change, but you have to communicate that. Because if you don't, if you don't, then it's gonna result in more silence. And I just loved reading through that.
Elaine Lin Hering (37:04.231)
Mm. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Elaine Lin Hering (37:12.541)
That that's how organization it's another way organizational silence comes into play, which is people will say, well, there's survey fatigue. No, it's actually inaction fatigue or perceived inaction fatigue. And there's so many different points of failure in that, which is maybe we have taken action, but we didn't make it visible to you. Maybe we did hear you, but we're planning on tackling that in Q4 rather than Q1 because of these different reasons.
Right. This is why my area of work and study and speaking is on communication, because the there is the reality of it, and then there is the communication and the messaging around it. And there are all sorts of lost opportunities as to did we hear you? What are we gonna do with this information? Is it actually anonymous? Because you know, someone came and followed up with me and then.
I was no longer invited to that meeting in the future. What whatever it is, that feeling of this there's no utility to it. You don't actually care because you haven't signaled to me that I heard you and that it might actually make a difference. If it's not gonna make a difference, why should I spend that five minutes? because I have better things to do with my time and my life.
Emre (38:33.87)
Exactly. And this just goes to show, once again, if we talk about the concept of being silenced or silencing someone, we obviously look at it from a good to bad, a villain versus a hero or a villain oppressing, silencing ordinary people. Where, but in reality, both the silencee and the silencer could be just well-meaning ordinary people.
Who are just trying to do their best, who are just trying to do their job. And so I exactly.
Elaine Lin Hering (39:06.303)
Or who have blind spots because we're human. But but because they're silence, it means I don't learn about the impact that it had on you because you don't think it's going to be worth it to communicate to me, or you think it's too risky to do so. And at the same time, if I actually want that input and feedback, I need to invite it because it might just be touching on someone's childhood or high school trauma.
Emre (39:35.779)
I love that. And as we approach towards the end of it, before we approach the before we hit the speed round, I just want to ask you, because you mentioned the impact, let's talk a bit about c the cost, the actual impact of silence in the workplace. There's an example you give early on in the book about Enron, right? About silencing risk assessment. And you mentioned that when there's something wrong, when there is, you know, when you know
Elaine Lin Hering (39:55.671)
Mm-hmm.
Emre (40:04.856)
The silence is building up, there are three ways people react to it. They either exit or they try to change the system or they stay loyal to it. So can you tell us a bit more about that example and what the cost of silence can actually be?
Elaine Lin Hering (40:22.015)
Yeah, the exit voice loyalty is Albert Hirschman's work from the 1970s around employee voice. That if people, like in an employee survey or otherwise, have tried to use their voice and it does not feel like it has been heard, then exit is you know, leaving is a natural choice. So exit is one option. Voice, you're actually heard, it feels like it made a difference, you get to have agency and impact.
Exit and voice. If exit and voice are two of the options and neither of them seems a legitimate or viable one for you, you can't find another job and people clearly aren't listening to you, then loyalty, another word might be compliance, is then the what all that's left, right? You can imagine that the good people try to use voice. If that doesn't work, they leave and they exit, good as incompetent, right? Who really want to contribute, who want to innovate, who are engaged.
And then you're left with only the people who are loyal to you. And some leaders and organizations maybe say that's fantastic. Actually, what we want are loyal soldiers who just do things and don't push back. Well, the downside of that is groupthink. The downside of that is actually at the core of every corporate scandal in the last 200 years, which is someone did try to say something, whether that is Enron or Facebook or, you know, take take your pick.
People did try to say something and they were met with resistance and silence and consequence that said, it's not worth it or it's not going to change. And therefore you're left with this echo chamber of loyalty. Now, what are the costs? This is a really interesting situation because there are short-term and long-term costs that even play out in any one individual's calculation of whether it makes sense to speak up.
Which is the costs long-term, our groupthink, corporate scandal, you know, the company might not make it, but those long-term costs don't show up for six, twelve, eighteen, twenty-four months. At which point, maybe the CEO, CMO, whatever it is, you're not there anymore, right? Leadership transitions happen all the time. Meanwhile, you're also building cynicism within your existing employee base because it's, well, you know what, they don't really mean the change.
Elaine Lin Hering (42:43.243)
This AI adoption thing won't really happen. I just need to outlive or outlast them. Versus the short-term costs of saying something are: I actually have to say something. I need to figure out the words right now. I don't have time to do it. I have to deal with their defensiveness. And so we tend to focus on the short-term costs when deciding whether to say something, but not calculate the long-term costs. Now
Part and parcel to that is there are benefits, both short term and long term, to using your voice. the benefits include something might change, something we actually have a chance to pivot and to problem solve. And that, and that's also not immediate, right? So the benefits of staying silent in the moment of I get to avoid it, I don't have to deal with it, let me go home and make dinner instead, right? Any of those things.
Human nature is to focus on the short term rather than the long term and focus on the rewards of staying silent right now and the benefits of staying silent and the costs of speaking up. And what HR and other leaders can do is shift the cost calculus. So we are incentivizing people to actually say what they think is wrong or not working, because that's what we do here on this team, because that's what gets you promoted.
That you were willing to say and call out the thing that didn't work or you thought was problematic so that we could pivot and problem solve earlier. and and that actually saved the company. Right. So the none of this is static. We get to have input into how costly it is for someone either to speak up or to stay silent. And again, what behavior we reward.
Emre (44:31.064)
Elaine, thank you so much. That was wonderful. And now we're heading in to the actual lightning round where I'm just gonna throw some fast-paced questions at you. And you don't have to answer them in so much detail, because if they want the detail, they can just get the book, you know. So the question is, which one in your opinion is harder to unlearn? Silencing yourself or silencing others?
Elaine Lin Hering (44:53.345)
Silencing yourself.
Emre (44:55.456)
Alright, and I want you to finish the sentence for me. Silence at work is
Elaine Lin Hering (45:01.035)
Dangerous.
Emre (45:02.67)
All right. And what is a small low risk way people can practice using their voice this week?
Elaine Lin Hering (45:11.735)
Choose something you don't really care about and do an experiment. Strangers are great to practice on. So, or or friends where you trust the relationship. And what I mean by that is maybe you're trying to figure out what to have for dinner with friends or family. Honestly, you don't really care. But experiment taking a position and using your voice in taking a stance.
You know, what do we all want to have for dinner? I'd like to have pizza. And people say, you know, I don't I'm sick of pizza. Well, you've literally lost nothing, but you have activated the muscle that tells you you could have an opinion, you can express that opinion, and nothing bad happens. So try a low-risk experiment expressing a point of view, especially when you don't really care about it. Because what that will remind you is you can do this.
It's okay, and you might even get what you want for dinner.
Emre (46:15.01)
Alright, well, Elaine, I'm just gonna try that now and say the Odyssey wasn't that captivating. I thought it was fine. I thought it was just fine. Visually, it was very impressing. The dialogue, not so much. The pacing, not so much. I liked what they accomplished, but honestly, it was just fine. Okay, I feel better. Now,
Elaine Lin Hering (46:24.043)
Yeah. Great.
Elaine Lin Hering (46:39.831)
Yeah.
By the way, you're still standing. You're still standing. For the record.
Emre (46:46.752)
I know, I know, crazy.
we'll see because the episode hasn't aired yet. So Elaine, you I think you know, lifelong learner, perpetually learning, that is one of the biggest buzzwords in LinkedIn. But you truly strike me as someone who does not stop learning because the way you have tackled this book, the way you tell the stories in this book, the way you just talked about narrating the audiobook and bringing your experience.
as you know a choir singer into that you s you truly struck me as someone who keeps on learning and keeps on looking at past experiences with a new perspective, with a new lens. So the last question here would be, what is something you know you've unlearned about silence since the book came out?
Elaine Lin Hering (47:40.657)
what have I not unlearned? What have I not unlearned? I mean, it is writing a book is a ginormous task. And writing a book about unlearning silence while unlearning your own silence is next level. I will say that the most important thing I have unlearned, or that I have learned, is that there is actually power to my voice.
And I had to unlearn that deference that you actually described in high school of everyone else must have a better opinion, everyone else must know, everyone else has secret sauce and abilities that I don't have. And that is one of the fastest ways we give away our power and agency is to assume that everyone else knows better or more than us. They they do know different than they know differently than us because they are different human beings.
So I have had to unlearn the deference to other people. And a colleague actually said to me, you know, because I I was saying, well, doesn't everyone know this? And they're like, no, that is the textbook definition of expert blindness that you assume, because it's obvious to you, you assume every it's obvious to everyone else. Let me go on record and say what is obvious to you, whether a behavioral challenge, whether a policy idea, whether a a
An opportunity for change that is obvious to you is not obvious to everyone. And so the power of your voice is is often what do you see and notice that others might not see and notice? And because we all sit in different roles in different parts of the globe, there is literally no one who can see the world as you do.
If you are struggling to own that point of view, though, my favorite phrase, we'll do this as a last bonus, is from where I sit, right? From where I sit, that timeline doesn't make sense. From where I sit, I don't understand how we're gonna balance the budget. From where I sit, we don't have the resources. Now, from where I sit doesn't mean it could couldn't look different from where you sit. It naturally begs the question: well, what do things look like from where you sit in Turkey? Because I'm sitting in California.
Elaine Lin Hering (50:01.303)
Right. And then we're in conversation rather than conflict. So my challenge and invitation to anyone listening is own your perspective from where you sit, because there is no one in the world who can be you, and we need you.
Emre (50:19.086)
I mean, Elaine, from where I sit, this has been a wonderful conversation and it's been so amazing to have you on the show. Where can people find you? How can they reach you?
Elaine Lin Hering (50:30.793)
ElaineLinHering.com is my website. There are free resources there, reading guides, cheat sheets, phrases, more like from where I sit. And also if you're someone on social media, I'm on LinkedIn and Instagram. Let's hang out.
Emre (50:46.848)
And if you're listening to us on iTunes, Spotify, wherever you find wherever you find podcasts, leave us a like, subscribe, it really helps the show out. And if you're on the lookout for an employee engagement slash performance management software, and you're in the Microsoft ecosystem, you can't go wrong with the highest rated one in the Microsoft Teams App Store. Teamflect. If you want to learn more, you can click the link in the description. This has been the Team Check-In. Bye bye, everyone. All right, Elaine, this was so much fun. It was great having you on the show.
Elaine Lin Hering (51:10.465)
Thank you.
Yeah. Thank you. Thank you for reaching out and having me. a joy to be in conversation with you. Even gallbladder free.
Emre (51:20.84)
Likewise, I mean especially I don't who would have like especially maybe it would have impacted my conversation. Maybe it would have, you know, impacted something. I don't know. Yeah. Thank you. I'm good. All the parts they can take out of me are out. You take care of your removable stuff. You never know.
Elaine Lin Hering (51:25.558)
I know.
Elaine Lin Hering (51:32.625)
Mostly stay healthy. Stay healthy and take good care of yourself.
Okay. Okay.
Elaine Lin Hering (51:44.331)
I got an extra liver, I think.
Emre (51:45.423)
Exactly. Elaine, thank you so much for coming on and doing this. It's been great, you know, getting in touch with you, reading your book, hearing your story. So thank you so much and have a great rest of your day. give me one.
Elaine Lin Hering (51:50.025)
Of course.
Elaine Lin Hering (51:55.244)
Thank you. You too. Take good care.
