Episode 47: The Silence Your Engagement Survey Can’t Hear feat. Elaine Lin Hering

Hear Elaine Lin Hering, author of Unlearning Silence, on why employees stop speaking up at work, and why a falling survey response rate is a sign of inaction fatigue.

When engagement survey responses drop, most companies blame survey fatigue. Elaine Lin Hering sees something else: people stop answering once they’ve learned that speaking up won’t change anything. In this episode of the Team Check-In, host Emre Ok sits down with Elaine, former Harvard Law School lecturer and author of the USA Today bestseller Unlearning Silence, to unpack silence as she defines it: the withholding of self for the comfort and convenience of others.

Elaine traces how the silence we learn growing up follows us into the workplace, and why telling people to “just speak up” rarely works. She shares the habits that shut colleagues down without anyone noticing, like the Friday 9 a.m. meeting that lands at 4 a.m. for the engineer with the key insight. She also walks through Albert Hirschman’s exit, voice and loyalty model to show what silence ends up costing a company, and what HR can do to change the math.

Chapters

  1. 04:35Silence as "the withholding of self"
  2. 09:44Learned silence and the baggage we bring to work
  3. 12:52When staying silent makes sense
  4. 15:57Levers HR can pull to invite voice
  5. 25:03How HR spots a culture of silence
  6. 31:04How we silence others: post-processors and 4 a.m. meetings
  7. 37:12Survey fatigue or inaction fatigue?
  8. 40:22Exit, voice, loyalty and the real cost of silence
  9. 47:40What Elaine unlearned, and "from where I sit"

Key Takeaways

1. Silence is the withholding of self. Elaine defines it as holding back your thoughts and expertise to spare someone else discomfort, which costs teams the very insight they hired for.

2. Healthy silence is a choice. The line between strategic and oppressive silence is agency. Biting your tongue because you’ll raise it one-on-one later is a decision. Staying quiet out of habit isn’t.

3. Name the expectation, then ask in pairs. Without stated norms, people default to the lowest-risk option. Asking “what works?” alongside “what doesn’t?” gives bad news a standard place to land.

4. Design time for post-processors. Some people do their best thinking 20 minutes after the meeting ends. Teams that only reward fast, in-the-room answers miss that slower, deeper thinking.

5. People stop answering surveys when nothing visibly changes. You don’t need to act on every response right away, but you do need to say what you heard and when you’ll get to it.

6. What you allow becomes the rule. When a senior rainmaker gets a pass on bad behavior, everyone notices. Leaders shift the cost of speaking up by rewarding the people who flag problems early.

‍

Speakers
Emre Ok
Product Marketing Manager
Teamflect
Elaine Lin Hering
Author
Unlearning Silence